Posted by Great Lakes Fishing Podcast on 19th Nov 2026
Early Season to Summer Kings: Captain Pete Alex Breaks Down Lake Ontario & Lake Erie Tactics
Captain Pete Alex from Vision Quest Sport Fishing starts his spring trolling for steelhead on Lake Erie. By late April, he’s usually in Wilson, New York, looking for trout and salmon on Lake Ontario. And if it’s been a mild winter, he’s ready to go looking for kings in 150 feet of water right out of the gate.
Pete runs Vision Quest Sport Fishing and joined me on Episode 147 of the Great Lakes Fishing Podcast. We talked about what makes a stretch of shoreline worth fishing for spring browns, how he sets up for steelhead in Presque Isle Bay, and which spoons he reaches for when he’s after Lake Ontario kings.
Find the right color for spring browns
When Pete is looking for spring brown trout on Lake Ontario, water color is the first thing he pays attention to. The water is cold just about everywhere at that time of year. What he wants to see is a stretch of green or light brown water where a fish can still pick out a bait without having to chase it far.
“Mud water is tough to catch these fish in. You want that green to light brown color — medium dirty water.”
It’s easy to spend too much time in a muddy stretch, especially if it’s a spot you’ve caught fish before. If the shoreline looks like chocolate milk, Pete would rather keep moving and find the edge where it starts to clear.
March steelhead in Presque Isle Bay
Pete typically gets going in March on Lake Erie’s Presque Isle Bay. The bay gives him a place to fish when spring winds make the open lake too rough, and there’s a good class of steelhead in there. A lot of the fish he catches are two and a half years old and run about 18 to 22 inches.
“They’ve been eating emerald shiners all winter. Fat, silver fish — just primo table fare.”
Pete runs spoons on his downriggers and divers, then sends shallow-running stickbaits out on planer boards. He likes stickbaits around three inches long and mixes bright colors with natural patterns to see what the fish are taking that day.
Be ready to fish deeper when you get to Wilson
By late April, Pete usually moves to Wilson to fish the early trout and salmon bite around the Niagara Bar. A lot of anglers think of early May as the start of king fishing there, but Pete has had some excellent king fishing in late April.
After a mild winter, less ice on Lake Erie and warmer water coming down the Niagara River can move that bite up. The fish can also be farther offshore than you’d expect for the date. If you’re used to setting up in 40 or 50 feet of water on your first trip, Pete says to be ready to run out to 150 feet or more.
That’s why he wants divers, leadcore, copper, and weighted steel ready from the first trip. Once he finds fish, those setups give him options for getting his baits down to them.
The spoons Pete keeps coming back to
When I asked Pete to spill the beans on his favorite king spoons, he had them ready. Here are the patterns we talked about:
- 42nd Spoon
- Rambler, with a black base, crushed orange and glow tape, and a silver or white back
- UV Alewife
- Two-Face
- Moon Cricket
- Black UV patterns with natural finishes
Pete has seen plenty of spoons get hot for a year or two and then settle back into the rotation. A bait that seemed to take a fish every trip one summer might spend most of the next summer in the box. As Pete put it, “That’s part of the mystery that keeps fishing fun.”
What changes after the morning bite
Pete talks about his spoons in terms of an A-team, B-team, and C-team. His A-team gets the first shot in low light, when he likes glow backs and patterns that show up well. As the morning goes on, he starts making changes based on cloud cover and how deep he’s marking fish. In bright sun and clear water, he’ll reach for chrome backs, natural finishes, blacks, and purples, with less glow in the spread.
Of course, if a spoon is still taking fish when the sun comes up, it stays out. If it goes quiet, Pete is quick to give something else a turn.
The same goes for what he runs on his long lines. I asked Pete whether he’d fish a flasher and fly or a meat rig on the same copper or leadcore he uses for spoons. “Absolutely — just the same as a spoon,” he said.
When the kings spread out
As the season goes on, the early concentration of fish around Wilson starts to break up. Some kings move along the shoreline and others slide offshore. Pete might find one group in 60 to 120 feet of water and another out in 120 to 350.
That’s the part of the season Pete enjoys. You have to decide how long to work the fish you’ve found and when to pull lines and go looking for another group. As he said, “I’d rather have a tough bite than a bonsai bite. Except in tournaments.”
If you’re making your first trip to Wilson this spring, get the deep gear ready before you leave home. You might start in 50 feet of water, but it’s good to have everything rigged if the fish are a couple hundred feet out.
Hear the full conversation with Captain Pete Alex in Episode 147 of the Great Lakes Fishing Podcast. For more Great Lakes trolling tactics and captain interviews, subscribe to the podcast and visit the Fish Hawk Electronics Blog.